Back to Home
Investment Law

Subcontractor Has Not Been Paid for Completed Work: How Can They Claim Their Dues Under Egyptian Law?

A subcontractor may complete the agreed construction work only to face delayed payment certificate approvals, rejected payment applications, or disputes over additional work. However, failure to approve a payment certificate does not necessarily eliminate the right to claim payment. Egyptian law provides legal mechanisms for establishing completed work, assessing outstanding amounts, and pursuing payment claims.

Author
Mr. Salem Mahmoud
Published on
min read
1 min read
50
Subcontractor Has Not Been Paid for Completed Work: How Can They Claim Their Dues Under Egyptian Law?

1. When Is a Subcontractor Entitled to Claim Payment for Completed Work?#

Subcontractors may face payment disputes despite fulfilling their contractual obligations. Such disputes commonly arise in several situations:

  • The subcontractor completes the agreed work, but the main contractor delays approving payment certificates.

  • Payment certificates are rejected despite completion of the relevant work.

  • Certain completed items are approved while others are excluded without a clear justification.

  • Additional work is performed following instructions or approvals from project management, but payment is subsequently refused.

  • The value of completed work is reduced following a unilateral assessment or pricing review by the main contractor.

In these situations, it is important to distinguish between merely submitting a payment certificate for review and establishing an actual entitlement to payment.

A payment certificate is an important supporting document, but it is not necessarily the only evidence of a subcontractor's financial entitlement.

The legal position depends on the subcontract agreement, the nature of the completed work, the applicable approval and payment procedures, and the supporting project documentation.

2. Does Failure to Approve a Payment Certificate Prevent a Subcontractor from Claiming Payment?#

Not necessarily.

The rejection or non-approval of a payment certificate does not automatically extinguish a subcontractor's right to claim payment for completed work. The reason for the rejection, the actual performance of the work, and its compliance with contractual specifications must all be examined.

For example, if a subcontractor has completed the work and possesses supporting documents such as quantity measurements, handover records, and project correspondence, these documents may provide evidence supporting a payment claim, even where approval remains disputed.

However, some construction contracts establish technical or administrative approval as an essential stage in the payment process.

Accordingly, the contract must be reviewed to determine whether non-approval affects the payment entitlement, the payment due date, or the procedures required before payment becomes enforceable.

3. How Can a Subcontractor Prove the Value of Completed Work?#

Establishing the existence and value of completed work is one of the most important stages of a payment claim, particularly when the main contractor disputes the quantities or denies certain items.

The following documents and evidence may be particularly relevant:

1. The Subcontract Agreement

The agreement identifies the assigned scope of work, agreed prices, payment certificate procedures, payment deadlines, and the contractual obligations of both parties.

2. Payment Certificates and Quantity Measurement Records

These documents help establish the quantities performed and their financial value, including certificates that have been submitted but remain pending approval.

3. Handover Certificates and Technical Reports

These records may demonstrate which works have been completed, the consultant's or project management's position, and whether any technical defects or outstanding observations remain.

4. Project Correspondence and Instructions

Emails, official correspondence, variation orders, and instructions issued by authorized project representatives may provide important evidence that specific work was requested, approved, or carried out.

5. Financial Documents

Invoices, payment receipts, previous payment records, account statements, and financial claims help establish the total amount due, payments already received, and the outstanding balance.

6. Site Photographs and Daily Progress Reports

Dated photographs, site records, and construction progress reports may help establish the performance and timing of the work, especially when disputes concern actual quantities or the scope of execution.

The evidentiary value of these documents varies depending on their authenticity, relevance to the project, and consistency with the contractual records.

4. What Should a Subcontractor Do If the Main Contractor Refuses to Pay?#

When payment is refused, the subcontractor should approach the dispute systematically to preserve evidence and contractual rights rather than relying solely on verbal requests.

The following steps may be appropriate:

1. Review the Contract and Payment Obligations

Examine payment terms, certificate approval procedures, payment deadlines, applicable deductions, and any contractual dispute resolution provisions.

2. Prepare a Detailed Statement of Outstanding Amounts

This should identify:

  • The value of completed work.

  • Payment certificates submitted.

  • Approved but unpaid amounts.

  • Additional work claims.

  • Previous payments received.

  • The remaining outstanding balance.

3. Document Objections to Rejected Payments

Identify the disputed payment certificates and individual items, request written explanations for rejection or deductions, and preserve all related correspondence.

4. Submit a Formal Payment Demand

The demand should specify the completed work, the outstanding amount, and the supporting documents, while providing an appropriate payment deadline in accordance with the contract and applicable legal requirements.

5. Evaluate Settlement and Litigation Options

If amicable demands fail, the subcontractor may consider appropriate legal proceedings to recover the outstanding amounts.

Depending on the nature of the dispute, an engineering or accounting expert may be required to assess completed work, determine its value, and calculate the outstanding balance.

5. Can a Subcontractor Claim Payment for Additional Construction Work?#

Additional work is one of the most common sources of disputes in construction projects, particularly when the main contractor requests work outside the original contractual scope and later disputes its approval or value.

The key legal questions include:

  • Who instructed the subcontractor to perform the additional work?

  • Was the work approved by a person authorized to issue such instructions?

  • Was a price or pricing mechanism agreed upon?

  • Are there documents establishing the quantities and work actually performed?

  • Were the additional works included in a revised payment certificate, variation order, or final account?

Under Egyptian law, Articles 657 and 658 of the Egyptian Civil Code are particularly relevant to certain additional work situations.

Article 658 addresses increases in remuneration where the contractor undertakes modifications or additional work under a lump-sum contract. Article 657 concerns situations involving quantities exceeding the estimated measurements in contracts based on unit prices.

Depending on the circumstances, the law may require notification, authorization, or agreement regarding the additional remuneration. Certain requirements may also involve written documentation.

Therefore, it should not be assumed that every additional item performed automatically entitles the subcontractor to claim any amount it independently determines.

Documenting approvals, instructions, quantities, and prices before starting additional work is essential to reducing disputes over entitlement and valuation.

6. Can a Subcontractor Claim Outstanding Payments Directly from the Project Owner?#

One important legal issue subcontractors should consider is that their recovery options may not always be limited to pursuing the main contractor.

Article 662 of the Egyptian Civil Code provides subcontractors with a specific right to claim directly from the employer amounts owed to the original contractor, subject to the conditions established by law.

Importantly, this direct claim is limited to the amount that the employer owes the original contractor at the time the claim is brought.

Before relying on this legal mechanism, several issues must therefore be examined:

  • The existence of a subcontracting relationship connected to the disputed work.

  • Evidence establishing the completed work and the resulting payment entitlement.

  • Whether amounts remain due from the project owner to the main contractor when the claim is filed.

  • The amount that may legally be claimed within the limits of Article 662.

Accordingly, a direct claim against the project owner may provide an important legal recovery option in certain circumstances. However, it does not mean that the project owner automatically becomes liable for all debts owed by the main contractor to subcontractors.

7. What Is the Role of Engineering and Accounting Expertise in Construction Payment Disputes?#

In some disputes, the disagreement extends beyond whether the work was completed. It may also involve actual quantities, technical compliance, or the calculation of outstanding payments.

Engineering and accounting expertise may help assess the claim through:

  • Inspecting completed work and comparing it with the contractual scope.

  • Determining actual quantities and comparing them with submitted payment certificates.

  • Examining additional work and the instructions under which it was performed.

  • Reviewing agreed prices and subsequent contractual variations.

  • Calculating payments already made and outstanding balances.

  • Examining deductions and reductions in payment to determine whether they are supported by contractual documents.

Such expertise can provide a clearer technical and financial assessment of the dispute, whether during settlement negotiations or court proceedings.

8. Common Mistakes That May Weaken a Subcontractor's Payment Claim#

Certain mistakes may make it more difficult to establish and recover outstanding payments.

These include:

  1. Performing additional work without documenting the relevant instructions or approvals.

  2. Failing to retain copies of payment certificates, correspondence, and handover records.

  3. Relying on verbal agreements when determining prices and quantities.

  4. Failing to submit written objections to deductions or reductions in payment.

  5. Not preparing a clear statement of outstanding amounts and previous payments.

  6. Suspending work or withdrawing equipment and labor without assessing the contractual and legal consequences.

  7. Delaying legal action without reviewing applicable limitation periods, prescription rules, or contractual deadlines.

Subcontractors should treat payment certificates and financial claims as an essential part of contract administration rather than merely accounting procedures.

Legal review becomes particularly important when the issue goes beyond an ordinary administrative payment delay and develops into a contractual or financial dispute.

Examples include:

  • The main contractor refuses to acknowledge completed work.

  • Outstanding amounts are reduced without the subcontractor's agreement.

  • Approvals for additional work are denied.

  • Disputes arise over defects, delays, deductions, or contractual liability.

  • The main contractor refuses to settle the final account.

  • The main contractor is unable to pay while outstanding amounts remain due from the project owner.

In these circumstances, legal review can help examine the subcontract agreement, payment certificates, correspondence, and technical documentation to identify the legal basis of the claim, determine the appropriate party against whom it may be pursued, and assess settlement or litigation options.

How Can a Law Firm Assist?#

Construction payment disputes require an understanding of contractual obligations, technical project requirements, and financial assessment procedures.

Through construction contract drafting and review services, as well as the management of construction-related disputes, a specialized legal team can assist with:

  • Reviewing main construction contracts and subcontract agreements.

  • Assessing financial claims and unpaid payment certificates.

  • Reviewing additional work documentation and variation orders.

  • Preparing formal legal payment demands and supporting claims.

  • Evaluating the possibility of direct recovery from the project owner under Article 662 of the Egyptian Civil Code.

  • Managing settlement negotiations and pursuing appropriate legal proceedings.

Failure to receive payment does not necessarily mean that a subcontractor has lost the right to claim the value of completed work.

However, a successful claim depends on establishing the contractual scope, actual quantities performed, agreed prices, and the relevant payment obligations, while reviewing the contractual procedures governing payment entitlement.

Egyptian law also provides, in specific circumstances, a mechanism allowing subcontractors to claim directly from the project owner for amounts owed to the main contractor, subject to the conditions and limitations set out in Article 662 of the Egyptian Civil Code.

If you are a subcontractor facing delayed payments, rejected payment certificates, or disputes over additional construction work, it is important to request a legal review of your case documents and an assessment of the available options before taking any action that could affect your contractual or financial rights.

Share Article
Annual Performance Bonus Disputes: Which Documents Determine Entitlement?
Investment Law

Annual Performance Bonus Disputes: Which Documents Determine Entitlement?

Disagreements over annual performance bonuses frequently arise when employees leave a company before bonuses are paid or performance evaluations are finalized. Determining whether a bonus is legally payable requires examining employment contracts, company incentive policies, performance reports, and relevant financial records.

Specialized Legal & Economic Consultation

Need an evaluation of your legal or investment case?

Our elite legal advisors provide in-depth evaluation of your transactions, disputes, and investments with absolute confidentiality.