How Can a Company Measure the Cost of Contracts Entered Into Without Proper Internal Approval?
Executive Quick Takeaway
A company can measure the economic cost of contracts entered into without completing the required internal approval procedures by assessing the resulting financial obligations, operational and legal r...
Detailed Legal & Advisory Answer
A company can measure the economic cost of contracts entered into without completing the required internal approval procedures by assessing the resulting financial obligations, operational and legal risks, and their impact on the company's budget, cash flow, and profitability.
The cost is not limited to the contract value itself. The company may also incur additional expenses arising from unauthorized contracting, including cancellation costs, renegotiation expenses, dispute resolution costs, and the financial consequences of obligations that have already arisen.
The assessment should cover several key areas:
1\. Contractual Financial Commitments: Identifying the total amounts committed by the company, including payments due, future obligations, and potential contractual penalties.
2\. Cost of Work or Services Already Performed: Determining the value of goods delivered or services performed, the benefits received by the company, and any resulting financial obligations.
3\. Cancellation or Contract Modification Costs: Estimating cancellation penalties, renegotiation expenses, and the costs required to rectify the contractual arrangement.
4\. Legal and Administrative Expenses: Calculating costs associated with contract reviews, dispute resolution, internal investigations, and addressing procedural violations.
5\. Cash Flow Impact: Measuring how unauthorized contractual commitments affect liquidity and the budget available for other business activities and projects.
6\. Potential Future Financial Risks: Assessing possible claims, compensation obligations, or losses resulting from unclear contractual commitments or disputes over signing authority.
Illustrative Example:
Assume a manager signs a supply contract worth EGP 1 million without completing the required internal approval procedures. The company has already paid EGP 300,000, while the costs of resolving or renegotiating the contract amount to EGP 50,000.
The total amount paid and additional expenses would therefore reach EGP 350,000.
However, this figure does not necessarily represent the company's final financial loss. The company must also assess the value of the supplies received, its remaining contractual obligations, the possibility of cancelling or modifying the agreement, and whether it is legally required to perform the contract.
How Can Companies Reduce the Cost of Contracts Without Proper Approval?
Companies can minimize these risks by establishing a clear financial and administrative authority matrix, defining signing and approval limits for each management level, and linking contract execution to a documented internal approval system.
Legal and financial reviews before signing, separating negotiation, approval, and execution responsibilities, and conducting periodic contract audits can also help identify violations early and reduce unplanned financial commitments.
A detailed financial report should identify contractual obligations, amounts paid, additional expenses, and potential risks. This enables management to assess the actual impact of unauthorized contracts on the company's financial position.
Grounding in prevailing Egyptian regulations
Drafted by senior attorneys and consultants
Important Professional NoticeThe guidance provided here is for general informative purposes and does not constitute formal legal counsel for a specific dispute. Consult our attorneys to review your case documents and specifics.