How Can a Company Measure the Cost of Contracts Entered Into Without Proper Internal Approval?
Executive Quick Takeaway
A company can measure the economic cost of contracts entered into without completing the required internal approval procedures by identifying the resulting financial obligations, estimating additional...
Detailed Legal & Advisory Answer
A company can measure the economic cost of contracts entered into without completing the required internal approval procedures by identifying the resulting financial obligations, estimating additional expenses and potential risks, and assessing their impact on liquidity, budgets, and business profitability.
However, the full contract value should not automatically be treated as a financial loss. The company may have received goods, services, or other economic benefits in exchange for the payments made. Therefore, it is essential to distinguish between total contractual commitments and the actual financial losses resulting from unauthorized contracting.
The assessment should cover the following areas:
1. Contractual Financial Obligations: Identifying the total contract value, payments already made, future installments, and outstanding commitments.
2. Value of Benefits Received: Assessing the value of goods, services, or completed work received by the company and whether they meet its requirements and specifications.
3. Cancellation or Modification Costs: Calculating cancellation penalties, renegotiation expenses, and the costs of correcting the contractual arrangement.
4. Legal and Administrative Expenses: Estimating contract review costs, internal investigation expenses, and dispute resolution costs.
5. Cash Flow Impact: Measuring funds committed or paid without prior planning and assessing their impact on financing other business activities.
6. Potential Financial Risks: Estimating possible claims, compensation, and penalties while considering their likelihood rather than automatically treating them as confirmed losses.
Illustrative Example:
Assume a company enters into a supply contract worth EGP 1 million without completing the required internal approval procedures. It has already paid EGP 300,000 and incurred an additional EGP 50,000 in contract resolution and renegotiation expenses.
The financial position can initially be summarized as follows:
| Item | Amount |
| -------------------------------------- | ------------- |
| Contract Value | EGP 1,000,000 |
| Payments Made | EGP 300,000 |
| Additional Resolution Costs | EGP 50,000 |
| Total Payments and Additional Expenses | EGP 350,000 |
However, EGP 350,000 should not automatically be classified as a final financial loss without assessing the value of supplies received, the benefits obtained by the company, outstanding obligations, and the possibility of recovering payments or modifying the contract.
How Can Companies Reduce Losses Resulting From Contracts Without Proper Approval?
Companies can reduce these risks by establishing a clear financial and administrative authority matrix, defining signing limits for each management level, and requiring documented internal approvals before entering into contractual commitments.
Financial and legal reviews before signing, separating negotiation, approval, and execution responsibilities, and conducting periodic contract audits can also help identify violations early and minimize unplanned financial obligations.
Preparing a separate financial report for each unauthorized contract also helps management identify financial exposure, measure its impact on cash flow and profitability, and make informed decisions regarding corrective action and settlement.
Grounding in prevailing Egyptian regulations
Drafted by senior attorneys and consultants
Important Professional NoticeThe guidance provided here is for general informative purposes and does not constitute formal legal counsel for a specific dispute. Consult our attorneys to review your case documents and specifics.