Electronic Payments Are Completed Instantly, but What Happens to Merchants' Money?#
For consumers, electronic payments often appear straightforward. A customer selects a product, completes the payment, and receives confirmation that the transaction was successful.
However, from a merchant's perspective, completing the transaction is only one stage of the financial process.
The proceeds must still be processed, reconciled, and transferred according to the contractual arrangements between the merchant and the relevant financial service provider.
This distinction became particularly relevant following an official circular issued by the Central Bank of Egypt on August 12, 2025.
The circular instructed banks to ensure that proceeds from domestic electronic Point-of-Sale transactions are settled exclusively in Egyptian pounds.
The requirement became effective on August 17, 2025, reflecting the regulatory framework governing payment transactions within Egypt.
Although the directive does not establish new deadlines for transferring merchants' funds, it provides an opportunity to examine the contractual safeguards businesses should consider when using electronic payment services.
What Did the Central Bank's Directive Actually Require?#
The regulatory instructions addressed three principal matters:
1. Settlement Currency: Banks must ensure that proceeds from electronic POS transactions conducted within Egypt are settled in Egyptian pounds.
2. Customer Notification: Banks must communicate the relevant settlement requirements to their customers.
3. Foreign Currency Requirements: Banks must continue addressing customers' foreign currency needs according to their respective policies and applicable regulations.
The directive became applicable on August 17, 2025.
Importantly, the requirement concerns the currency used to settle transactions. It should not be interpreted as establishing universal deadlines for transferring merchant proceeds or creating new compensation rights for delayed payments.
This distinction is particularly important when assessing payment disputes and contractual responsibilities.
Could Regulatory Changes Affect Existing Payment Service Agreements?#
Many businesses rely on agreements with banks, payment processors, and financial technology companies to collect payments from customers.
These agreements often regulate several important aspects of the financial relationship, including settlement schedules, transaction fees, refunds, payment disputes, and the circumstances under which funds may be withheld.
When regulatory requirements change, businesses may need to examine whether their existing contractual arrangements remain consistent with the applicable legal framework.
For example, an agreement involving particular settlement currencies or cross-border payment arrangements may require additional scrutiny.
However, a regulatory directive does not automatically invalidate existing contracts or require every merchant to renegotiate its agreement.
The legal implications depend on the nature of the payment services, the scope of the regulatory requirements, and the specific contractual provisions involved.
Delayed Payments and Unexpected Deductions: When Can a Commercial Dispute Arise?#
Electronic payment disputes may arise when merchants experience delayed settlements, unexpected deductions, or restrictions on access to transaction proceeds.
These situations can have significant financial consequences, particularly for businesses that depend on continuous cash flow to meet operational obligations.
Nevertheless, not every delay or deduction necessarily represents a contractual violation.
1. Delays Within Contractually Agreed Settlement Periods#
Payment service agreements may establish processing periods before funds become available to merchants.
Where the provider complies with the agreed settlement schedule and applicable regulations, the existence of a processing period does not automatically constitute a breach.
2. Delays Beyond the Agreed Deadline#
A different legal situation may arise when a payment provider fails to transfer funds within the agreed period without a valid contractual or legal justification.
Depending on the agreement and circumstances, the merchant may have grounds to request performance, challenge the delay, or pursue compensation where the relevant legal requirements are satisfied.
3. Disputed Deductions or Suspended Merchant Balances#
Payment service providers may apply deductions or temporarily restrict access to certain amounts for reasons connected to refunds, chargebacks, fraud prevention, risk management, or regulatory compliance.
The legitimacy of such measures must be evaluated against the contract, applicable regulations, and the factual circumstances.
Businesses should therefore avoid assuming that every withholding of funds is unlawful or, conversely, that every deduction is justified merely because it appears in standard contractual terms.
Which Contractual Provisions Should Merchants Review?#
The regulatory development highlights the value of reviewing payment service agreements before financial disputes arise.
Several contractual provisions deserve particular attention.
Settlement Currency and Payment Timelines
Merchants should verify whether their contracts clearly specify the settlement currency, applicable processing periods, and conditions governing the transfer of proceeds.
Transaction Fees and Deductions
Payment agreements should explain how fees are calculated, when deductions may occur, and whether providers can modify charges without advance notification.
Account Restrictions and Reserve Requirements
Some payment arrangements permit providers to retain reserves or temporarily suspend settlements under specified circumstances.
Businesses should understand the conditions triggering these measures and the procedures available for reviewing or challenging them.
Complaint and Dispute Resolution Procedures
Contracts should establish transparent mechanisms for submitting complaints, reviewing disputed transactions, and resolving disagreements.
Depending on the circumstances, these mechanisms may include negotiation, mediation, litigation, or commercial arbitration where a valid arbitration agreement exists.
What Should Merchants Do When Payment Disputes Arise?#
When a merchant experiences a disputed settlement, unexpected deduction, or delayed payment, the first step should be to identify the contractual and financial basis of the disagreement.
Relevant documentation may include the payment service agreement, transaction reports, settlement statements, bank records, invoices, and correspondence with the provider.
A comparison between the amounts expected and the amounts actually received can help establish the nature and extent of the disputed sums.
Where the dispute concerns a bank regulated by the Central Bank of Egypt, the merchant should follow the applicable complaint procedures.
According to the CBE's published banking complaint framework, complaints must generally be submitted to the bank concerned first. Banks are generally expected to respond within 15 working days, subject to exceptions, including certain transactions involving external entities.
This timeframe should not automatically be applied to all non-bank payment service providers, whose complaint procedures may be subject to different regulatory requirements.
If the dispute remains unresolved, the next steps depend on the relevant contractual provisions, applicable law, and competent regulatory or judicial authorities.
Why Payment Settlement Transparency Matters for Business Liquidity#
For companies operating online, revenue growth does not necessarily guarantee financial stability.
A business may report strong sales while simultaneously experiencing cash flow pressures if transaction proceeds are not received when expected.
Delayed access to funds can complicate inventory purchases, supplier payments, payroll obligations, and operating expenses.
Therefore, merchants should monitor the period between the date of a sale and the date the proceeds become available.
They should also regularly reconcile payment reports, investigate unexplained differences, and assess the risks associated with depending heavily on a single payment provider.
Where commercially appropriate, diversifying payment collection arrangements may help reduce operational exposure, although such diversification also involves additional costs and contractual considerations.
Could Payment Settlement Disputes Lead to Commercial Arbitration?#
Disagreements between merchants and payment service providers may involve contractual interpretation, disputed deductions, delayed transfers, or alleged failures to perform financial obligations.
Depending on the parties' agreement and the applicable legal framework, some disputes may be resolved through negotiation or commercial arbitration.
However, arbitration is not automatically available in every payment dispute.
Its availability generally depends on the existence and validity of an arbitration agreement, as well as the legal nature of the dispute.
Carefully drafted digital payment agreements can reduce uncertainty by clearly defining financial obligations, settlement procedures, liability provisions, and dispute resolution mechanisms.
Conclusion: Regulatory Compliance and Contractual Clarity Are Both Essential#
The Central Bank of Egypt's August 2025 directive regarding POS settlement currency demonstrates the importance of clear rules governing electronic payment transactions.
While the directive specifically addresses settlement in Egyptian pounds, it also provides a useful context for examining the broader contractual relationships between merchants, banks, and payment service providers.
For businesses relying on electronic payment systems, understanding settlement conditions, transaction fees, fund restrictions, and available dispute resolution mechanisms can help reduce financial uncertainty and protect commercial interests.
If your business is experiencing delayed settlements, disputed deductions, or disagreements with a payment service provider, a professional legal review of your payment agreements and an assessment of the financial impact can help identify your contractual rights, obligations, and available resolution options.



