Construction Project Remains Out of Service Despite Completed Works: When Is the Contractor Liable for Defects?
A construction project may appear complete, with its main building and installation works finished. However, this does not necessarily mean that the project is ready for operation or formal handover.
In some cases, technical testing reveals problems that were not apparent during construction, creating disputes over responsibility between the project owner, the contractor, and the supervising parties.
The issue has gained attention following an official statement concerning the Al-Faqai Water Station in Beni Suef Governorate, where the Holding Company for Water and Wastewater clarified that the station had not yet entered service and remained under the responsibility of the executing contractor.
A Water Station Under Testing: Why Has the Project Not Been Formally Accepted?#
On July 25, 2026, the Holding Company for Water and Wastewater issued a statement addressing reports concerning an operational issue at the Al-Faqai Water Station, which has a production capacity of 100 liters per second.
The statement explained that the station had not yet entered service and remained in the trial-operation phase. It had also not been formally handed over to the Beni Suef Water and Wastewater Company.
The company further announced that the National Research Centre had been assigned to prepare a specialized technical report to examine the situation and assess the relevant technical aspects before determining the appropriate measures.
This incident highlights the importance of technical testing as a fundamental stage before project acceptance, particularly when verifying compliance with contractual specifications and operational requirements.
Does Completing Construction Automatically End Contractor Liability?#
Under Egyptian law, completing construction works or handing over a project does not necessarily eliminate every legal obligation imposed on the contractor.
Liability depends on several factors, including the nature of the defect, the contractual handover conditions, when the defect appeared, and whether it affects the safety or structural integrity of the building.
Article 651 of the Egyptian Civil Code establishes a ten-year warranty for architects and contractors against total or partial collapse of buildings and defects that threaten their structural integrity or safety, subject to the statutory requirements.
However, this warranty should not be confused with contractual obligations concerning ordinary defects or non-compliance with technical specifications. Not every construction or finishing defect automatically falls within the scope of the ten-year warranty.
What Do Egyptian Court Rulings Say About Contractor Liability After Handover?#
The Egyptian Supreme Administrative Court addressed aspects of this issue in Appeal No. 5221 of Judicial Year 55, in a judgment dated July 28, 2015.
The judgment addressed the ten-year warranty and the responsibility of contractors and architects to ensure the structural integrity and safety of buildings during the statutory warranty period.
It also discussed the commencement of the warranty period from the date of final handover and the limitation period applicable to warranty claims under Article 654 of the Egyptian Civil Code.
The application of these principles, however, depends on the specific facts of each dispute and the legal requirements governing the relevant construction works.
Engineering Reports and Handover Certificates: Why Do They Matter?#
When technical problems emerge in a construction project, the dispute is rarely limited to determining whether a defect exists.
The parties must also establish its cause, when it appeared, and whether it resulted from defective execution, design errors, unsuitable materials, or other factors.
Several documents can therefore become essential evidence, including:
Technical testing reports: To assess whether completed works comply with contractual specifications and technical standards.
Initial and final handover certificates: To establish the stage of delivery and any recorded reservations.
Consultant engineering reports: To document technical observations and corrective work.
Construction contracts and specifications: To identify the obligations undertaken by the contractor.
Inspection records: To document the condition of the works and when defects were discovered.
Expert reports: To assess technical causes and the potential extent of the damage.
A technical report alone does not automatically establish legal liability. Its evidentiary value depends on its findings, technical basis, and consistency with the other available evidence.
Who Bears the Cost of Repairing Construction Defects?#
Determining responsibility depends on the nature and source of the defect, as well as the contractual and legal obligations of each party.
A defect may result from non-compliant execution, unsuitable construction materials, design errors, inadequate supervision, or other circumstances requiring specialized technical examination.
Responsibility may also involve more than one party, depending on the facts and available evidence. Disputes can arise between main contractors and subcontractors over the work performed by each party.
Consequently, identifying the party that physically carried out the work is not always sufficient. The contractual arrangements and the allocation of technical and legal responsibilities must also be examined.
How Can Companies Protect Their Rights in Construction Projects?#
Preventing construction disputes should begin when the contract is drafted and continue throughout execution and final handover.
Important risk-management measures include:
Clearly defining technical specifications and quality standards in construction contracts.
Establishing procedures for inspections and technical testing before handover.
Recording observations and reservations in formal handover documents.
Clearly allocating responsibilities among contractors, consultants, and subcontractors.
Defining procedures for correcting defects and approving remedial works.
Retaining contracts, technical reports, and execution records throughout the relevant legal periods.
Companies should also review applicable statutory deadlines and contractual notification requirements, as delays in taking legal action may affect the ability to pursue available claims.
The Key Takeaway: Handover Is More Than a Signature#
The Al-Faqai Water Station incident highlights the importance of distinguishing between physical completion of construction works and successful technical testing, operational readiness, and formal acceptance.
In construction projects, handover certificates and engineering reports are not merely administrative documents. They can become essential evidence in determining contractual rights and responsibilities when disputes arise over defective execution or repair obligations.
For property owners, developers, and contractors, reviewing construction agreements, documenting execution and handover procedures, and obtaining timely legal and technical assessments are important steps toward reducing risks and protecting contractual and financial interests.



